We welcome J.S. Lewis to WriteOnCon! It’s always great to have fabulous middle grade authors, and he’s one of the best! Today he’s divulging some tips for writing middle grade.
Writing For Middle Grade…Or, Welcome to Neverland
Warning! If your childhood is nothing but a distant memory, stop reading!
Seriously. You see, if you really want to write for the middle grade market, the passions of your childhood must be a vibrant part of your world today!
If you’re poisoned by the realities of the world, turn back. If you’ve been jaded by politics, financial scandal, and sensational news stories, it’s hopeless. And most importantly, if you find yourself using phrases like, “when I was your age . . .” you are, I’m afraid, terminal.
However, if you’re the kind of person who frequents eBay in search of that special My Little Pony your mother sold in a garage sale, or if you go to Target in search of bath towels, but end up in the toy section looking at Star Wars figures, you’re well on your way to becoming a beloved middle grade author.
Sound ridiculous? Maybe, but here’s the thing. Kids know. They know if you have a real passion for what you’re writing about, and if you’re trying to sell them a story that isn’t saturated with passion, they’re going to reject it. If you still live in Neverland though – if you have stories with young heroes and heroines that are screaming to be told, then you’ve found a home.
When I was approached to take part in this revolutionary writing conference, I asked the creators what subject matter would help most. They gave me a list, but instead of focusing on one, I think I’ll touch on a few. Like kids, I have a short attention span, so it’ll help me stay focused. In turn, hopefully it’ll give you a wider perspective on the subject as a whole.
Times Have Changed, And They’re Changing Fast
I was asked to lecture at a writing conference where I ended up reviewing two manuscripts. It’s something I never do, and I hated it. I rarely read books that friends of mine have written because I’m brutally honest. I don’t know how to fake enthusiasm, so I’d rather avoid the discomfort of telling someone that I don’t like what I read. The problem, though, is that if you don’t hear fair criticism, you’ll never grow.
Someone who looked to be in her sixties wrote one of the manuscripts. It was a touching story that would have been perfect for a Hallmark movie of the week, but (in my opinion) it wasn’t going to work as a story for kids. Why? The characters were right out of Leave It To Beaver or My Three Sons. They were the children from her youth, but not kids from today.
One thing I’ve learned is that it doesn’t matter if you’re writing a script for a movie or television, or if you’re writing a book. Kids hate retro. I mean, how nostalgic could a twelve year old actually be?
To solve that problem, you have to inundate yourself with where your target market is at today. What are their language patterns? What music are they listening to? What television shows do they watch? Who are their heroes?
I’m lucky. I have three kids. But I’d watch Spongebob Squarepants, Ben 10, Fairly Odd Parents and Star Wars Clone Wars even if I didn’t. If you don’t have access to kids, volunteer at the children’s section of your library. You could teach Sunday school for the grade level(s) that you’re writing for. Offer to host your friend’s kids for the weekend. Watch the Disney Channel or Nickelodeon to study the humor and dialogue cadence. You’ll be amazed by what you learn!
You’re Not Alone . . . Even Four Year Olds Think Elmo and Dora are Lame
Kids are growing up faster than ever. Each one of my kids was done with Sesame Street and Dora by her third birthday. Say what? I watched Sesame Street until I was in kindergarten. What happened?
Whether or not we like it, kids are growing up faster than ever. You can fight it, or you can use that knowledge to your favor because it’s a small but critical point. Kids want to read stories about people who are older than they are. So if you’re writing for 10-12 year olds, consider making your heroes and heroines 14. There’s something alluring when it comes to gettng a glimpse of what the future holds, and aging your characters will make your stories more compelling to a middle grader.
How to Keep Kids Turning Those Pages
Kids don’t want to read. Sure, we can all come up with examples of a kid (maybe even five) who loves to read, but those numbers are dwindling. Librarians and educators are desperate for stories that attract those reluctant readers (i.e. boys). It’s a battle that the schools are losing.
Can you blame kids for not wanting to read, though? Books, by nature, require a serious investment of time. It can be intimidating – even for an adult – to look at a book and wonder if they will have time to finish it.
The competition for “free” time is unrelenting. There are video games where you can customize your characters to look exactly like you, or better yet, exactly like what you’d want to look like. The worlds inside those games are nearly photorealistic – it’s almost as though you’ve become a character in a movie.
Then there’s social media, texting, sports, homework, television, movies, and slew of other activities. With all of that available to them, when are kids supposed to read for leisure?
If you get lucky enough to have a kid pick up and open your book to the first page, you better start off with a bang! You have to grab them and never let go.
If your story starts to lull, your reader is going to put it down and he or she won’t come back – not just to that book, but most likely any book you write in the future.
Here are a few thoughts on how to keep that momentum going . . .
* Adjectives and adverbs are not your friends
My advice? Eliminate modifiers except where absolutely critical (which is rare). Logic would state that you’re helping create a rich environment when you add a lot of description. What adjectives and adverbs actually do is bring your story to a screeching halt.
* Keep ‘em guessing!
You need at least one character that will keep your readers guessing. Is that character friend or foe? Then, just when the reader is sure where that character stands, make them do the exact opposite of what would be expected. Use this character to keep your audience off-balance. Twists and turns in the plot will keep kids engaged – they love to be on the edge of their seats. We all do!
* Action
Kids – especially boys – love explosions, fights, monsters, aliens, robots, and all that jazz. Don’t be afraid to include it in your stories. There’s a trick though . . . it can’t come at the expense of story. If you haven’t created characters that your reader connects with on a deep, emotional level, they won’t care what happens when your characters get in trouble.
* Tension
Tension can be as important as action (and it’s probably more important). Look at any Alfred Hitchcock film. There weren’t a lot of explosions, but the tension in his stories keeps you on the edge of your seat. Apply that to your writing. Kids love suspense.
* Cliffhangers
Some people consider the use of cliffhangers a cheap trick. Maybe it is. However, you need to create a reason for the reader to keep going. What better way than to finish each chapter with a bang that’s going to lead into something even more exciting in the next chapter?
I remember sneaking under my covers with a flashlight, reading a book long passed my bedtime. Why did I risk getting grounded? Because every time I went to put the book down, the author compelled me to keep reading – it was as though I didn’t have a choice but to disobey my parents. You need to create that same sense of desire so kids won’t be able to put your book down. At the end of every chapter, the little voice inside their heads should say, “okay, just one more chapter . . .”
Tackling Delicate Subject Matter
Don’t be afraid to tackle real issues. One of the themes in the Grey Griffins series that I co-authored is divorce. It affected my main character in a deep way when his parents split up, just like it affected me and millions of other kids. I didn’t judge whether or not his parents should have gotten a divorce, but I wasn’t afraid to talk about his pain. That resonates with kids.
Why not touch on the struggles that your readers are going through? Peer pressure . . . fitting in . . . self-confidence . . . moving away from the town where you grew up . . . acne . . . rejection by the opposite sex . . . we all went through it, and so are kids today. Tapping into those universal struggles may help you create a deep emotional connection with the reader.
Just be careful that you don’t get too graphic when it comes to subjects like abuse and other violent or sexually explicit acts. Your editor will be a great barometer to help you when aren’t sure about something.
Wrapping It Up
I’ve already gone well passed my word count, so I’ll close with this. Writing for middle grade readers is exciting. You’ll never have a more enthusiastic group. And in truth, if I can do it, you can (and I’m not just saying that)! So if this is really your passion, stick with it and never give up.
Oh, and read a ton of middle grade books in a variety of styles. Check out beautiful prose like Laini Taylor, as well as the wonderful economy of words that writers like Kate DiCamillo use. I have a list of books and authors that I’ve enjoyed here — listen to the cadence of their sentence structure and try and discover the “why” behind what you like and dislike.
And keep learning! I know that I’ll never stop reading books on writing. I feel my writing has grown exponentially over the last six months because of some excellent books, podcasts and audio series that I’ve discovered.
I have a list of great books that I try to read once a year. You can find that here.
Good luck! And if you have a question that I didn’t address here, you can always email me at jslewis@greygriffins.com. I’d love to help if I can.
J.S. Lewis is an American novelist and comic book writer. His novels include Invasion (coming December 2010), as well as The Brimstone Key (from the Grey Griffins Clockwork Chronicles), and the original Grey Griffins trilogy: The Revenge of the Shadow King, The Rise of the Black Wolf, and The Fall of the Templar (co-authored by Derek Benz). He also wrote a twelve book comic book series based on Sony’s virtual world phenomenon, Free Realms. A graduate of Arizona State University’s Walter Cronkite School of Broadcasting, Lewis has explored a career that includes news reporting, radio production, animation, graphic design, web development, mural painting, speech writing, video game development, voice over work, and marketing. He currently resides in Arizona with his wife and children.



Love this. Thank you!
I don’t write middle grade material, at least not yet and who knows what the future holds, but a lot of what is said here resonates true for what the rest of us write as well. Thank you for coming and sharing your insight with all of us.
Just read this on Elana’s blog;great post. Excellent advice and I’d watch Spongebob, Star Wars and I’m in the Band even if I didn’t have kids!
I’m not young-at-heart enough to write MG, but most of your advice applies to all good stories. Thanks!
J.S.,
Great stuff! I just finished rereading Peter Pan… and Neverland never gets old.
Best Wishes,
Joseph
This is my favorite age group, probably because I taught middle school for seven years. Your comments are great. You made me feel better about the fact that most of what I read and watch on tv is targeted for this age group.
As a contributing member of “From the Mixed-Up Files…” this is a topic we discuss often. Keeping middle-graders engaged, interested and investing them early on to the world of reading. Thanks for the post – it’s validated all we’re working on at The Mixed-Up Files!
This is so true (especially the bit about ending up in the toy aisle). Glad to see stuff directed at MG writers!
Nice. Everytime I go into Toys R Us I feel like its Christmas. I think I enjoy it more than my kids. Nice to know I’m not alone.
Great tips.
That was a well-needed slap in the face! Not in a bad way either. I write MG and these are points I will definitely take home with me. Thanks!
I LOVED this post! Excellent advice!
So I was totally justified watching Sesame Street this morning even though my kids were not? Whew. Good to know. The biggest plus for me is not only having kids in the ages that I write for, but involving them in my writing. I know if something instantly works or not. And you’d be surprised what they have to offer the story (and don’t even care if they get credit for).
Thanks for all the great advice!
Great post J.S.
I found myself nodding my head and smiling through it all.
There is an error to the first link. Do you also have those books listed on your website – the ones you try to read one a year?
Man! When you started out with “Warning! If your childhood is nothing but a distant memory, stop reading!” I was thinking, like, what? Yesterday? Given a choice, who wouldn’t want to play or laugh or be BFF with lots of kids? I could be of grandparent age, if my “kids” would oblige. That said, my hubby will often come home to find me watching TeenNick. Caught! Don’t care, either. It’s just nice to be validated for my choices.
You gave some awesome advice. (Oops; dates-me term.) Middle Grade Rocks! (dating, again) Thank you. (a timeless phrase at last)
Excellent advice. I’m fortunate to have a first grader, a sixth grader and I teach high school. I have the best of all three worlds – well, most days. And I would seriously watch Star Wars and ICarly all day if I could.
So, JS Lewis, I’m hoping you might pop by to answer a follow-up question that’s been plaguing my brain! Like some of the other commenters, I’m not a MG writer at this point, but your advice was spot-on for anyone. And my question is this: writers should avoid modifiers, I get that. They’re tell-y rather than show-y, right? But what do you suggest, then about dialogue? Pros I read say to avoid dialogue tags as much as possible & use actions instead to id speakers. Cool. But sometimes, people are just talking. These same pros suggest using only “said” or maybe the occasional “whispered” or “yelled.” Not whined, snickered, etc. I miss having more variety w/ tags. In life, HOW someone says something in a conversation can be more important than what they say. So, writers can’t use modifiers or anything other than said? I’d love to hear you weigh in on that!
Hi J.S. I really enjoyed your post. A cool combination of advice and encouragement. I clicked on your link to books and authors that you enjoyed but it was broken. I’d love to take a look at that list. I’m well-read in YA but am wanting to read more middle grade.
Thanks!!
My son was a very reluctant reader in first grade. I’d have to force him to pick up a book every night, even though he chose the books. Then we went to see the Percy Jackson movie (Yes, I get that it wasn’t true to the book, but that’s irrelevant to my point). Since then, he’s been gobbling up books like candy. The biggest problem is he loves the PJ books, and we have yet to find another series he’s willing to glom onto. Hoping it happens soon since he’s on The Last Olympian
I guess the point of this is a lot of people (and educators) discount the power of movies and television. A mediocre (at best) interpretation of a kids’ book got my son interested in reading.
I love writing YA, but I also loved high school. I’ve tried my hand at middle grade, and I’m not sure I can manage it — that time of my life was just a little too painful. I have the utmost respect for people who can though
Excellent advice. I was just watching Avatar: The Last Airbender (again!) with my kids this morning. Best cartoon ever
I heard about the Grey Griffins trilogy from the boys in my sons class — they all read them in 4th and 5th grade. I’m adding them to my own pile, too.
Loved this! I have three sons (13 and two 10 year olds) and what you say is true: we are competing for their time, and the digital stuff often wins the battle.
Thanks so much for participating in this conference.
Terrific post and excellent advice!!
I had to laugh when I read your remark about eBay. How did you know I’’m always on eBay desperately trying to find two books from my childhood? The one that I would dearly love to find had a stuffed toy that came with the book, The Story of Ophelia written by Mary Le Duc Gibbons and published by Doubleday, 1954. I loved that toy. The other book is Black Penny by Phoebe Erickson.
Great post.
I tried to go to your list of books you love, but I got a forbidden note.
Any suggestion?
I love your passion for MG! What an awesome article, it’s the best I’ve ever read on how to communicate to MG. Brilliant!
This is spot on advice, which I needed to hear again. Thank you! A note on older MC’s, though. Make sure your MC isn’t older than middle grade age. I’ve done that, and even though kids still love to read it, editors and agents seem to have a checklist that forbids it. So 14, sure. But don’t put them any older than that if you can help it! I’m off to rewrite mine younger.
Well, it is a good thing to know that I am not alone in the toy aisle!
Great advice.
Shelley
This is tough love writing advice. Love it.
Deb (Salisbury), you made a great point . . . genre or reading level aside, good writing is good writing, and though kids may be a little more forgiving, they know the difference. Thanks for stopping by!
Terrific advice! It’s funny, just last night my husband and I were talking about how we have no self-control when it comes to reading–we just can’t put down a (good) book, no matter how late it gets at night. Must be the cliffhangers at the end of each chapter!
Kelly (Hashway),
Never feel guilty! The people who grew up are the ones we should have pity on. Life is too short.
Amie (Borst),
Happy to help in any way I can!
WONDERFUL advice! I’m revising my first MG novel and so many of my concerns were addressed here. I’m breathing easier now. Thank you!!
Carrie (Dair),
My kids come up with great stories. Kids are brilliant! They just need an outlet.
What fantastic advice! Thank you so much for this. What you said bout kids wanting to read about kids older than themselves is absolutely true – my daughter is 9-1/2 and an avid reader, and seem more interested and comfortable in reading about girls in middle school, around 11-13 years of age. The biggest problem I have found as a parent is while she may be capable of reading the words on the page and understanding the story arc, the content isn’t always age-appropriate. A 13 year old grapples with much different feelings and issues, or at least at a different depth, than a 9-1/2 year old would, and I’m not ready to let mine out of the garden enough that I want her reading books with lots of kissing or more or drugs, etc. Yes, it’s a different world and yes, she’s aware of these issues, but I believe there is a huge market for books that fill exactly this gap, catering to that age group.
The best part of being a parent is getting to play. The best part of being a kid-lit writer is that I get to read kid books! Thanks so much for this discussion — I’m getting out my scissors now to cut all my adjectives.
This totally rocked. I love watching kids and teens shows, and reading their books. Stars Wars Clone wars rocks. And my favorite Disney show is Suite Life with Zack and Cody. And I love superhero cartoons.I am looking forward to Young Justice this fall. And I am starting to get hooked to Phineas and Ferb. Those guys are hilarious.
I visit Neverland on occasion. But I frequent Narnia, Middle Earth, and Oz. I don’t reside anywhere as I live in my TARDIS (Time Machine). And am always looking for new worlds to explore.
So about that broken link……
Great post! Definitely gave me good fodder as I work on my current WIP. So much to think about! But I’m with you, I’d be watching the cartoons even if I didn’t have kids.
[...] so far today? Writing Middle Grade (probably my favorite topic to date, & I’m by no means an MG writer), Queries, Finding [...]
The only “nostalgia” that I can think of that kids have accepted (and this was a few years back) is That 70′s Show. And it’s more for YA, and even adults, certainly not for the younger children.
Thanks for all your wisdom!
I just rescued my collection of My Little Ponies from my mom’s give-away pile a couple months ago–no joke. Wonderful advice all around! You make me feel great about writing middle grade books.
I have written two middle grade books (not published yet) and I remember one of my former 6th grade students reading an early draft. When she handed me back the manuscript she said, “Mrs. Walton, the good part on page 19, well, you need to move that to your first page.”
Out of the mouth of children, eh?
I base a lot of my writing after my husband- he does not read for fun now because schools lost his attention with what teachers gave and forced him to read when he was young. By junior high, he didn’t care, and I can’t get him to read a thing, though he loves to watch History channel etc. He says the books in school were boring, and like J.S. said, lacked any sort of action, they were “old”, and too slow.
I agree with the post, and my goal in writing middle grade is to reach readers like him, who may read IF they find something interesting. GREAT article : )
You make excellent points. If you can’t remember what it was like to be a child and don’t spend time with children, how can you write for them?
Thanks for your advice! You are SO right — the books I loved as a child? Can’t get my daughter to read them. I’m talking Elizabeth Enright (The Melendy Family series, Gone-Away-Lake) and Edward Eager (magic that happens to ordinary kids — cool!). And even Madeline L’Engle’s “A Wrinkle in Time” didn’t grab her. We had to read it TOGETHER in order for her to finish it. But Percy Jackson — oh, yeah! (I have to admit, I lost sleep for about two weeks staying up late, reading that whole series myself.) Franky, I’m glad I have a nine-year-old who orients me to the present. I love the books of my childhood, and they are still in print — but they are not the books of today!
Thanks again,
A. B. Williams
“At the end of every chapter, the little voice inside their heads should say, “okay, just one more chapter . . .” This made me laugh out loud–and I STILL do this as an adult (I’m sure many of us do).
I’m currently trying to decide whether my new project is going to be YA or MG, but after this post, I’m leaning towards MG. Thank you so much for the great advice!
Great advice. I hope I can keep my passion for kids at middle grade as my daughter moves onto the teenage years. I’m going to keep your tips for action, keeping them guessing, tension, and cliffhangers as I revise my chapters.
Sorry to slap you, Leona (Broberg). It was an accident. I would never hit a lady!
Shauna, here are the links that were missing . . .
Books on Writing: http://www.jonslewis.com/?page_id=266
MG books I like: http://www.jonslewis.com/?page_id=311
Authors and other links: http://www.jonslewis.com/?page_id=138
More links:
Writing TIps: http://www.jonslewis.com/?page_id=25
Blog: http://www.jonslewis.com
Twitter: @jonslewis
I guess the links aren’t working. Here you go:
* Books on writing: http://www.jonslewis.com/?page_id=266
* MG books I like: http://www.jonslewis.com/?page_id=311
* Authors & links I like: http://www.jonslewis.com/?page_id=138
Other links . . .
* Writing tips: http://www.jonslewis.com/?page_id=25
* Blog: http://www.jonslewis
* Twitter: @jonslewis
Kirsten,
It’s not just that modifiers are “tell-y” rather than “show-y” — think of it like your driving down the freeway at 75 mph, and suddenly the asphalt turns to a pool of tar. You go from smooth sailing to plodding. Eventually your car would stop. The make the reading experience slow down, and generally speaking that is a really, really bad thing — especially for kids.
As to dialogue, I made some HUGE mistakes with my first three books when it comes to modifiers. However, I would definitely try and stick with “said” as much as possible. The reason is that anything else brings attention to the modifier instead of what is being said. Your mind (as the theory goes) will eliminate the existence of “said” — so even though it’s there, you really won’t pay attention to it any more.
As to showing and not telling, yes. Let the emotion of your character or what your character is doing accentuate the dialogue.
Bad Example: “I’m sick and tired of this!” he said angrily.
Better Example: Tom smashed his fist on the desk. “I’m sick and tired of this!”
See the difference? Purists hate “ly” adverbs attached to dialogue, and (as part of my ongoing education) I can see why.
Paul (Greci),
Sorry for the mixup on the links, but if you look a couple posts above (I believe the hyperlinks are a beautiful pink color) they will lead you to the links that you’re looking for.